2008-2009 State Budget
Senate Republicans Respond to Governor's Budget Address

 

Senate President Pro Tempore Joe Scarnati (R-25)  Senator ScarnatiSenator ScarnatiSenator Scarnati

"Good effective government does not include taxing, borrowing and spending.  They have to be controlled, and they have to be used in the best way for our economy."

Senate Majority Leader Dominic Pileggi (R-9)  Senator PileggiSenator Pileggi

"We can't borrow and spend our way into prosperity.  An extraordinary amount of new debt is proposed, and I'm not sure that that level of debt is the right level to do what we need to do to stimulate our economy -- it might have the opposite effect."

Senator Lisa Baker (R-20)  Senator BakerSenator Baker

"I'm very concerned about the new levels of spending, increased taxation and borrowing. So we have to look very closely at the ramifications of those proposals because I'm not convinced that's the best approach."

Senator Jake Corman (R-34)  Senator CormanSenator Corman

"I think the rush to try to subsidize health care is the wrong way to go.  What I'd like to focus on is the affordability of health care."

Senator Jane Earll (R-49)  Senator EarllSenator Earll

"We really need to determine what our top priorities are, exercise some fiscal discipline, use tax policies to stimulate the economy, and then we have to be mindful that in the current economic times that we're going to negotiate this budget within there are a lot of external factors that we need to take into consideration when we try to figure out how much we should be spending this year."

Senator John Eichelberger (R-30)  Senator EichelbergerSenator Eichelberger

"Very disappointing but pretty much what I expected. A lot of increased spending a lot of increased debt. No new reforms at all. No cuts. No alternative programs. No privatization effort."

Senator Mike Folmer (R-48)  Senator FolmerSenator Folmer

"I appreciate that he wants to put money back in the people's hands with a tax rebate check…my question is why take it in the first place? Let's have broad-based tax cuts across the board for everybody, not just for a certain class of people."

Senator Roger Madigan (R-23)  Senator MadiganSenator Madigan

"That's a concern to me, the bonding. Certainly we don't want to get into the mortgage situation, 'How can we pay it off?' I think we have to be very careful that we are able to pay off whatever bonding that we do."

Senator John Rafferty (R-44)  Senator RaffertySenator Rafferty

"Even though he says it's a light budget and he's curtailing spending, I think we can do even more. I have strong reservations about the borrowing he's anticipating. I know that he said he thinks Pennsylvania still ranks low among states with bond issues out and debt payment; however a governor of New Jersey probably said the same thing 10 years ago."

Senator Bob Regola (R-39)  Senator RegolaSenator Regola

"Unlike the federal economic stimulus proposal, which has a much broader impact, the governor wants to direct state tax money to a limited segment of the population and encourage them to spend it as soon as possible. I question whether that is a responsible use of the tax money that we are taking out of the pockets of working families, especially when so many Pennsylvania families are struggling just to make ends meet."

Senator James Rhoades (R-29)  Senator RhoadesSenator Rhoades

"The concerns I have [with the education budget] is it's changing now from the categorical operations we've had to more of a costing-out study type of thing. That costing-out is going to cost you close to $5 million. The governor says he feels the state should be responsible for half of that. Well then I have to ask, 'Where's the other half going to go to?' That begins to conflict with our effort to reduce school property taxes."

Senator Bob Robbins (R-50)  Senator RobbinsSenator Robbins

"There is a significant amount of spending and borrowing in the governor's proposal and we must determine how much of this is necessary and how much is just wishful thinking. I know many of my friends and neighbors in northwestern Pennsylvania are struggling just to keep up with the day-to-day cost of living."

Senator Tommy Tomlinson (R-6)  Senator TomlinsonSenator Tomlinson

"I like the educational initiative. I like the rewarding teacher training. I like rewarding new curriculums. I like rewarding test results. But the devil's always in the details. We have to see how it works out in my districts in Bucks County."

Senator Pat Vance (R-31)  Senator VanceSenator Vance

"I was not happy about the bond indebtedness. What he's proposing just this year would be a $1.9 billion increase in our bond indebtedness. And the first four years he was governor our bond indebtedness increased 32 percent."

Senator Mary Jo White (R-21)  Senator Mary Jo WhiteSenator Mary Jo White

"I think the thing I find truly astounding is that with the storm clouds gathering on the national economic front and everyone bracing for a downturn in the economy, the thought of raiding our Rainy Day Fund to make cash payments to people…The governor was calling them 'rebates,' but a rebate is when you pay something and get some of it back. These are for people who are not paying the Personal Income Tax who are going to receive a $400 payment out of the Rainy Day Fund."


Back to Top